Homemade Pies: Tips, Tools, & Recipes

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. We participate in other affiliate programs as well. For more details, please see our disclosure policy.

Want to learn to make stellar pies? I gotcha covered. Check out these tips, tools, and homemade pies you can dig into today.

freezer candy bar pie with server

Pictured: Toffee Dream Pie

If you’re a fan of pie, then you’re going to want to learn how to make homemade pie. You just can’t have one without the other. Not really. 

You see, I have been a pie lover since birth. I’d much rather have pie than cake. And as soon as I tasted Lemon Meringue Pie as a child, I decided that I had to learn how to make it myself. I was ten.

It took some trial and error, and yes, I did use a boxed mix of lemon pie filling at the beginning. 

And yes, I did accidentally put 1/2 cup of salt into the pie dough instead of 1/2 teaspoon….

… but eventually I arrived. And pies are my jam now, some 30+ years later.

As you’ve noticed already in about 100 words, is that I’ve learned from experience. Sometimes the hard way. Here are some things I’ve learned about baking pies and having them turn out well.

making a blueberry pie with heart cut out top

Pie Baking Tips

  • Homemade pie crust is better than the store kind. Like way. And healthier. And cheaper, too. You can make a batch of pie crust for about 80 cents, much less than the $2 to $4 each that you’ll pay at the store.
  • Pie dough ingredients should be cold. This will help give them a light and flaky texture. If your kitchen is warm, slide the pie plate into the freezer for a few minutes before baking.
  • Pie dough can be frozen for a later date. If you don’t get around to baking up your pie for whatever reason or want to have some pie dough on hand for spontaneous pie baking, you can freeze the unbaked dough. Wrap the round or the formed pie dish well with plastic wrap and stash it in the freezer.
  • Fruit pies can sometimes overflow in the oven. Due to the bubbling nature of hot fruit, sometimes your pie can overflow in the oven. To prevent a smoking, stinking oven, place your pie on a rimmed baking sheet before sliding it all in the oven. Any drips will be caught in the pan and not fall to the bottom of the oven where they will burn and smoke. Bonus points if you line the pan with some aluminum foil. Then you don’t even have to wash the pan.
  • Kids love to help you make pies. Don’t hesitate to let them help. My Gramma John’s Pat-in-Pan Pie Crust is super easy, even kids can do it.

mom and boy making apple pies together

  • Sometimes the top crust is baked before the filling is done. If you pull it out too soon, you’ll have a drippy, soupy pie. Bleh. To allow the filling more time to bake, cover the pie with foil to prevent over browning on top.
  • Cool the pie completely to allow the filling to set. As tempting as a warm piece of apple pie is, you may have a soupy, soggy mess if you cut into it too soon. Allow the pie to cool completely on a wire rack before cutting into it. If you want warm pie, reheat it in the oven or microwave before serving.
  • Many pies freeze beautifully! Fruit pies as well as savory ones freeze beautifully. Cream pies, not so much. To freeze a fruit or savory pie, wrap the unbaked pie gently but completely in heavy duty foil. Store it on a level surface in the freezer. When you’re ready to bake it, unwrap it, place it on a rimmed baking sheet (see tip #4), vent the top crust, and bake it at 425 degrees for 15 minutes. Reduce the heat to 375 and continue baking until the top is golden and the filling is hot and bubbly.
  • Make the top crust pretty. You can easily give your pie a beautiful top crust in just a few simple steps. Crimp the edges around your thumb or with a fork, create a lattice or layered cut-out top, brush the crust with beaten egg or milk, sprinkle it with coarse sugar. Any one or combination of these steps will make for a prettier pie.

pie dough crumbs in food processor and in bowl with pastry blender

Do you need special tools for baking pies?

You don’t really need special tools. You could pretty much make pie dough with a bowl and a fork, but there are some things to make the process quicker and easier. Here are the tools that I use for making pies:

  • food processor or pastry blender – Either of these tools make quick work of the short dough. You can do it by hand with two knives, but I prefer my food processor.
  • large cutting board – I use this super size cutting board for a work surface for all my doughs. I can easily clean and sanitize it and move it around the kitchen.
  • rolling pin – Necessary for making homemade pie crust.
  • plastic wrap – Too much flour can make your dough tough, but too little makes it stick to your work surface. I use plastic wrap to help me roll the dough easily and transport it to the pan without tearing it. Stretch-Tite is the best, in my opinion.
  • pie plate – obviously ?
  • liquid measure – these beakers are more accurate for liquids
  • kitchen scale – Love this one! I have had mine for over ten years. I weigh my flour instead of scooping it.

What are some great pie recipes?

I thought you’d never ask!

10 Great Homemade Pies You Can Make Today

Photo Credit: lifeasmom.com

Homemade Chocolate Cream Pie

Homemade Chocolate Cream Pie

Dig into decadent chocolate pudding topped with freshly whipped cream. The flaky crust adds just a touch of salty texture to make this pie amazing.

Continue Reading

Mixed Berry Pie with Cinnamon and Lemon

Mixed Berry Pie with Cinnamon and Lemon

A dusting of cinnamon and lemon zest in the crust takes a humble berry pie to new levels. Try it with cherries, too!

Continue Reading

Coconut Crunch Pie

Coconut Crunch Pie

This simple frozen pie takes only six ingredients, fifteen minutes, and no baking! It's light coconut flavor doesn't overpower, but has you coming back for more instead.

Continue Reading

Sorbet & Ice Cream Pie with Chocolate Ganache

Sorbet & Ice Cream Pie with Chocolate Ganache

Try this no-bake freezer pie with it's three beautiful layers: sorbet, ice cream, and chocolate ganache. Feel free to vary the flavors based on what you have on hand.

Continue Reading

Easy Blueberry Pie from Scratch

Easy Blueberry Pie from Scratch

Mix up a deliciously easy blueberry pie in about 20 minutes. While it bakes, your home will fill with the golden scent of baked pastry and the jammy aroma of simmering berries.

Continue Reading

Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Pie

Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Pie

Give pumpkin pie a little twist with the addition of chocolate chips. Make it easy with a store-bought cookie crust.

Continue Reading

Streusel Topped Pumpkin Pie

Streusel Topped Pumpkin Pie

Deemed the best pumpkin pie in the world, this streusel-topped number is a must-make, even if you have your own favorite pumpkin pie.

Continue Reading
Photo Credit: lifeasmom.com

Gramma John’s Blue Ribbon Apple Pie

Gramma John’s Blue Ribbon Apple Pie

Gramma John won blue ribbons with her apple pie and now you can, too. It comes together in minutes and bakes up beautifully.

Continue Reading
Photo Credit: lifeasmom.com

Lemon Meringue Pie

Lemon Meringue Pie

Master the art of meringue with this simple Lemon Meringue Pie recipes. Its mixture of tart and sweet, crunchy, smooth, and fluffy is utterly divine.

Continue Reading
Photo Credit: lifeasmom.com

Nanna’s Toffee Dream Pie – A Must-Make

Nanna’s Toffee Dream Pie – A Must-Make

My sister calls this Crack Pie. My mom calls it Toffee Dream. My kids call it Candy Bar Pie. Whatever you call it, it's good.

Continue Reading
Pie Tips, Tools, & 10 Great Homemade Pies You Can Make Today

About Jessica Fisher

I believe great meals don't have to be complicated or expensive. There's a better way, and it won't take all afternoon.

Subscribe to Good Cheap Eats
Read Newer Post
Read Older Post

Share Your Thoughts

*