Looking for a simple yet flavorful way to cook pork? This crockpot pulled pork combines a homemade rub with a cheap cut of pork, a pork butt, and cook it slowly in the slow cooker for a fantastic slow cooker pulled pork recipe.
When you sit down to meal plan, do you crave fun food that is easy to make and prime for the season? Fun food is what we want when we go out to eat or invite folks over, right?
Why not make it more often so that every week can have a little excitement?
What about a dish that is economical, too? I mean, few of us have money growing on trees so we need meals that fit the budget without tasting boring.
Frugal, fun food — that’s the question, isn’t it? Well, I’ve got the answer right here.
Some of my pre-requisites for frugal, fun food include the following:
- can be made in advance so you can go play at the beach, park, or lake – or go to work on a regular day and not worry about what’s for dinner.
- uses the slow cooker (or the grill, in summer) so as not to heat up the kitchen or make a huge mess.
- is versatile so that it can be mixed and matched in lots of ways; leftovers can take a new identity the next day without any awkwardness or boring feelings.
- invites you to customize it with all kinds of yummy sauces and toppings.
- won’t break the budget.
- fits a variety of diets so everyone can enjoy it
And this pulled pork recipe made in your slow cooker?
Well, it fits all those requirements and then some!
It’s no exaggeration to call this the Best Ever Slow Cooker Pulled Pork. It truly is amazing!
The custom spice blend is versatile so that it complements Mexican food (think tacos, burritos, enchiladas) just as well as it does classic barbecue sandwiches. It’s out of this world with this homemade BBQ sauce.
Pulled pork that you can serve in a myriad of ways makes for some super fun dinners; you won’t get bored easily.
It’s simple to make a very large batch of this pulled pork, depending on what size roast you buy. Pork butt or shoulder roasts are extremely affordable, so don’t hesitate to stock up.
Between the tacos and the sandwiches and just good eating alongside a dish of potatoes, this pulled pork proves to be a perfect busy night OR company dinner. Since the slow cooker does the cooking, you can take it easy either way!
What kind of meat do you use for crockpot pulled pork?
By nature, pulled pork needs to be made from a cut of pork that will become tender and basically fall apart after cooking. Pork butt and pork shoulder roasts fit the bill. These might also be labeled Boston butt or picnic shoulder.
Pork butt and pork shoulder roasts are perfect all year-round. Roasts cook up super well in the slow-cooker which is an ideal tool to use in the summer time as well as in the busy winter months. Not only do they save you from heating up the oven, but they can also sit for awhile cooking dinner while you finish your daily business.
Look for sales on pork butt or pork shoulder roasts. I’ve seen them as low as $1.99/pound in San Diego.
The roasts I bought for developing this recipe were huge, making for two meals for our family. I love cooking once and feeding my family multiple times. However, if your roast is significantly less than 8 pounds, use less of the spice mix.
Is pork butt the same as pork shoulder?
They are both from the shoulder of the pig, but pork butt is just higher up on the foreleg. Generally these are tough, fatty cuts which means they are cheaper in price.
They benefit from a slow cooking method like this recipe that utilizes your crockpot! The slow cooker will help to break down this tough, fatty meat into a juicy pulled pork you will want to pile high on bun with barbeque sauce.
What spices do you use for slow cooker pulled pork?
Using a blend of salt, pepper, garlic powder, onion powder, onion flakes, chili powder, ground cumin, cayenne, and cloves will give your pulled pork great flavor without a lot of work.
This custom rub smells so good. I purposely developed the spice mix to go with BBQ as well as Mexican flavors, so the possibilities of how to serve the final product are truly endless. Use the savory pulled pork in tacos, burritos, taquitos, chimichangas, lettuce wraps, salads, and sandwiches.
All the ingredients are gluten-free, making this great addition to a Whole 30 meal plan, paleo, and other gf diets.
Just be sure to check your chili powder package. Sometimes they add funky stuff to chili powder.
How do you make pulled pork in a slow cooker?
This recipe is super simple. You need a pork roast and a handful of spices.
Measure out the spices and mix them together. Place the roast in the slow cooker and coat it generously with the spice mixture. Cover and cook for 6 hours on high or 8 to 10 hours on low.
When the meat is cooked, it will pull apart easily with two forks or tongs.
Do I need to add water to the pulled pork?
Surprisingly no. You don’t need to add water to the roast and spices in the slow cooker. This cut of pork is naturally juicy, and yes, fatty. In just a few minutes it will juice up in the pot.
At the end of the cooking time, you should have a decent 1/2 to 1 cup of drippings. You can use these to moisten the meat, make soup or chili, or discard.
How do I shred cooked pork?
When this pulled pork is ready, it will easily fall apart. You can shred the cooked pork in the slow cooker or remove it to a dish. Simply pull the meat apart with a fork or tongs.
Moisten the meat with some of the drippings if you like.
How To Serve This Slow Cooker Pulled Pork
Once you have shredded the pork, it’s time eat! We love serving this piled high on a kaiser roll and you can drizzle on some of your favorite barbeque sauce.
You can even add a scoop of this Simple Coleslaw Recipe. Or maybe some Homemade Dill Pickles!
Then don’t forget the sides! Buttermilk Cornbread would be delicious. Macaroni Salad, Easy Mac &Cheese in the Instant Pot, or this Easy Homemade Deli Potato Salad would all make excellent side dishes.
Can I overcook pork in a slow cooker?
Yes it is possible to overcook the pork if on the high setting. If you use the low setting it’s almost impossible. So if you are worried about overcooking the pork then I recommend using the low setting.
Should you brown pork before slow cooking?
I didn’t bother with browning the meat before putting it in the slow cooker. The long, slow process will break it down the meat and create a juicy shredded pork.
However, that being said, you can by all means brown the meat on all sides before adding it to the slow cooker. Doing so, will just add more flavor. Nothing wrong with that.
Can I make this pulled pork recipe ahead of time?
You absolutely can! It will keep well in the fridge for about 4 days. Any longer, and I recommend freezing it. Keep reading for how to freeze this delicious pulled pork…
Can I freeze slow cooker pulled pork?
You can store it in a regular refrigerator freezer for about 6 weeks, longer in a deep freeze.
Note: food stored at less than zero degrees will stay good indefinitely, however it can lose some texture over time. If you cannot ensure that your freezer temps stay that low, use it up with 6 to 8 weeks.
How can I make this crockpot pulled pork cheaply?
Pulled pork is already a very affordable dish, thanks to the fact that pork roast is a cheap cut of meat. However, there are a few other things you can do to lower your costs even more:
- Stock up on ingredients when they are on sale. When you see a good price on pork roasts, buy a few extra to stash in the freezer for later. You know you’ll use them — especially when you make this pulled pork. Stocking up can save you money.
- Buy spices in bulk. I regularly buy larger containers of spices I use frequently, like pepper, sea salt, garlic powder, and chili powder. I store excess dried herbs and ground spices in the freezer if I know it will be awhile before I go through the large container.
Watch how easy it is to make this slow cooker pulled pork:
What kitchen tools do I need to make pulled pork?
This recipe really couldn’t be easier than it is, but having the right kitchen tools can really make your time in the kitchen more enjoyable. Over time, I’ve honed my collection so that they are perfect for my needs.
Here are the tools that I use for this recipe:
- 6-qt slow cooker – A must-have for this recipe.
- Ergo Chef cooking tongs – I love these! They are my favorite cooking tongs and good for serving as well.
- freezer containers – I love these Redi-tainers for freezing. I’ve got them in 64-ounce and in 32-ounce sizes.
If you prepare this recipe, be sure to take a picture and hashtag it #GOODCHEAPEATS. I can't wait to see what you cook up!
Best Ever Slow Cooker Pulled Pork
Ingredients
- 8 lb bone-in pork butt or shoulder roast
- 1 tbsp salt
- 1 tbsp garlic powder
- 1 tbsp onion powder
- 1 tbsp dry onion flakes
- 1 tbsp chili powder
- 1 tsp black pepper
- 1 tsp ground cumin
- 1/2 tsp ground cloves
- 1/4 tsp ground cayenne pepper or more to taste
Instructions
- Remove the roast from the packaging and place in the bottom of a large slow cooker.
- In a small bowl combine the salt, garlic powder, onion powder, onion flakes, chili powder, black pepper, cumin, cloves, and cayenne pepper. Spread this all over the roast, turning the meat to coat all sides.
- Cook in the slow cooker for 6 hours on high or 8 to 10 hours on low. The meat will be so tender that it will easily shred with tongs or two forks. Remove the bones and fat, and shred the meat.
- Serve the meat as a filling for tacos, sandwiches, lettuce wraps, burritos, salads, or taquitos.
Notes
Nutrition
Maureen says
The pork looks so tender and soft. And it can be really mix and match easily. It also definitely fits variety of diets. Yummy!
LeesaB says
We love pulled pork in my family, though my husband always smokes it. We then freeze it in 1-lb packages to pull out for quick and easy dinners. Typically chile verde, gumbo, moo shu pork, or bbq sandwiches in my family. I can see how the slow cooker would be great to finish the pork off during the summer if need be, though since he likes to smoke 4-6 butts at a time, that may have to be reserved for those emergency pork needs…
Jessica Fisher says
How nice to have a smoker!
Kat says
Do you need any liquid with this recipe? None listed although I realize you’d have condensation and fat from the meat.
Jessica Fisher says
I didn’t, but it was swimming in liquid. If you feel like you still want to, you can add 1/4 cup and you’ll be fine.
Heather says
You will have plenty of liquid from the meat cooking
Jessica Fisher says
Yep.
Alice E says
This looks good. I am new to rubs, but interested in trying them However, I don’t have sea salt and can’t eat black pepper. Would Kosher salt, canning salt or table salt work best? Would you make any other adjustments when leaving out the pepper? Do you think I could use crumbled summer savory leaves? Thanks for any suggestions. I have a couple of pork butt roasts waiting for me in the freezer. Oh, and have you ever tried the leftover pork in chili or with noodles, two of my usual destinations for leftover diced meat?
Jessica Fisher says
Kosher salt is good. The other adaptations you mention sound great.
Carol says
We love pulled pork in our family and use it as a base for a variety of meals as you mentioned. What I would like to know is that a homemade bun in the photo and if so would you share how to make them?
Jessica Fisher says
Those are my Everything Burger Buns and the recipe is coming this week! 🙂
Katie says
I got a screamin’ deal on a pork butt at Fry’s (Kroger affiliate in Arizona) and am making this for my frozen dinner club. Sometimes I let the recipients do the actual cooking, but since it’s such a large piece of meat, I am going to do the cooking, shred it, and let them just heat-n-eat. I’m contemplating making the homemade buns as well. 🙂
Jessica Fisher says
Sounds like a fun club to be in!
Cheryle says
What am I doing wrong? Whenever I make pulled pork in my slow cooker I always end up with lots of grease & meat that is still pink, even though it’s falling apart. If I keep cooking it all of the grease cooks into the meat. I buy the leanest pork shoulder/butt I can & usually it’s boneless. Any tips are appreciated.
Jessica Fisher says
I am not sure. I don’t buy the lean stuff, just the cheap stuff. Sorry that happens to you!
Cheryle says
Hi Jessica. Mine is cheap too. Believe me, I only buy it when it’s a really good sale. I just pick the leanest they have. 🙂
Jessica Fisher says
Looking over your comment again. Pink meat is okay if it’s reached a safe temperature. The USDA even lowered the safe level of pork in the last few years. Mine does make a lot of drippings. Thinking about putting it on a rack next time so it doesn’t sit in the drippings? You can make a makeshift rack out of foil if you don’t have one that fits your slow cooker.
jacqi says
A bit of fat is natural and helps with flavor and moistness. That said, too much is too much. Every slow cooker is different, but try a higher temp. I do like to add a little liquid to help steam meat and ensure even cooking. I lift the lid just once about three quarters into cooking, when meat is cooked thru but still chewy so that I can flip the meat over and get the top half immersed in some liquid. I like to remove done meat, and skim oil from top of the remaining liquid, then either crank setting up or boil the liquid in pan to reduce or stir in some thickener to cook. Wondra flour, corn flour, mashed potatoes, etc.
Renee says
I’m confused by your hashtags, recipes, and photos.. this and many other look like delicious meals, but are not at all whole 30. Rolls? Tortillas? Cheese… even alot of the ingredient lists, the sunflower oils, dairy etc. Again, I’m sure they’re great recipes, but shouldn’t be labeled or promoted as Whole30. For someone like myself wanting to truly meal plan for 30 days, there are way too many mods needed or things that aren’t w30 approved. just some thoughts.
Jessica Fisher says
If I’ve tagged something Whole30, I’ve included modifications either in the headnotes or the recipe itself. The pictures do not always correspond with the modifications. I apologize for the confusion.
Marie says
My husband loved this recipe!! So easy to make. I will be making again. Thanks for sharing!
Jill says
I made this overnight last night and I just have to tell you THANK YOU! It is absolutely amazing. It is the best pork I have ever made in the crock pot, hands down. I was skeptical because there was no liquid in the recipe, but I went with it anyway because of the comments. I am so glad I did. It is so good. The spices made kind of a crust on it and it’s just absolutely amazing. My store didn’t have any huge roasts so I bought 3 smaller ones to equal about what your recipe called for. Worked just fine. I tried to pick them up and they just fell apart! The meat is so moist and flavorful and not dry at ALL. Just insanely good. Thank you!
Jessica Fisher says
Yay! I’m so glad to hear that you liked it! Good work!
Margaret Lilley says
This came out super dry! We ended up using the leftover meat for enchiladas because it really didn’t stand alone. Followed the directions, so I’m not sure what happened.
Thanks for the lovely post…at least I got some great ideas from you. Love the blog, too!
Jessica Fisher says
I am sorry to hear that. It was a pork shoulder? Not all cuts do well with slow cooking. Other thought would be that it cooked too long? Usually this cut is so fatty that it’s always moist. Bummer!
Lisa says
I added a little dry vermouth to mine
Shirley Jaques says
There is a type-o in the directions – “Cook on low in the slow cooker for 6 hours on high or 8 to 10 hours on low.” It should read “Cook in the slow cooker for 6 hours on high or 8 to 10 hours on low.”
The recipe was great, I had to restrain myself from adding liquids, but in the end it was moist & had great flavor. I’ll make it again.
Jessica Fisher says
Thanks for the heads up! Glad you enjoyed it!
Kay Ross says
Do I divide the seasonings if my roast is only 2 pounds or do I still use the amount listed for an 8 pound roast? Sorry..I’m new to this cooking thing!
Jessica Fisher says
Just make 1/4 the batch or just use less if you’ve got a smaller roast.
Samantha says
Hello! I’m making this right now, I am new to cooking and have never used ground cloves. The smell of it is terrible to me, as its cooking it is kind of taking over the smell all together. Now I’m worried I put too much on accident or is that normal? Silly question I know! Lol
Jessica Fisher says
There is a distinct odor to cloves, so yes, you would notice it, particularly if you haven’t used it before. I made this this weekend but was out of cloves and I missed that scent. Hopefully, you didn’t put too much. Fingers crossed.
Christina says
I made this today and I used too many cloves. That’s all I taste ? I’m super bummed. I think next time I’ll leave the cloves out. It wouldn’t “ruin” the outcome correct?
Jessica Fisher says
No, you can omit it. Bummer that it was too much today!
Brenda OHearn says
I didn’t have cloves and mine was great! I actually misread the recipe the first time I made it and added a tbsp instead of tsp of cayenne pepper and realized it too late and my family (who likes spicy food) absolutely loved it!! It was just a little spicy but not overwhelming.
Jessica Fisher says
Good to know! Thanks for sharing, Brenda!
Patty says
Making this for our bible study tonight. It looks and smells awesome! Thanks!!!
Courtney says
I just bought my roast today at a organic farmers meat store, it’s frozen. I want to cook it for tonight, have u ever cooked it in your crockpot frozen? Any tips?
Jessica Fisher says
It’s generally not recommended to cook a frozen roast because the inside can be at unsafe temperatures for a very long time, allowing bacteria to grow. http://www.fsis.usda.gov/shared/PDF/Slow_Cookers_and_Food_Safety.pdf I would recommend thawing it overnight and cooking it tomorrow.
Alice says
I do not like pulled pork with vinegar or barbecue sauce so I decided to try this for a family gathering. It was a huge hit, many comments on how it was the best they’ve ever had! At first I thought all the liquid would make it greasy, but shredding it made it soak in and it was perfectly moist and yummy. Thanks.
Jessica Fisher says
SO glad you enjoyed it. I feel the same way about the vinegar and BBQ! #greatminds 😉
Chris says
Best rub ever! I have slaved over making this until now, thanks for sharing! God bless you!
Jessica Fisher says
Glad you like it. I used the rub on grilled pork tenderloin this weekend and it was really good that way. If you’ve got leftover rub, use it for grilling.
Annette says
What if it has no bones..do I add water or let some of the fat make the juice
Jessica Fisher says
I don’t add water because there’s enough fat and juice in conventional pork. I might do something different if I was using organic, but that’s not in the budget at this time.
Nedra Bryce says
I made this today! It turn out delicious! It was my first time making pulled pork. Thank you for the recipe.
Jessica Fisher says
So glad you enjoyed it!
Lisa says
I am making this for the 2nd time today because my “picky eater” husband loved it so much the first time I made it. We are going to a New Year’s Eve party and he insisted that I make this so we could share it with our friends. When he likes something this much, trust me, it must be really good!! I also usually freeze the left overs so we can heat-and-eat whenever we want, but I doubt there will be any left overs this time. Thank you so much for sharing this! It is a hit!!!!
Jessica Fisher says
Yay!!!! That’s how I feel every time I make it. Like, wow! I made this?! So glad you will rock the party tonight!
Heather says
Gonna make this sometime this week. I am soooo excited!!!!??? One question, though, I didn’t realize it was supposed to be bone-in so I bought a boneless because it was cheaper. Is there anything different I should do?
Love your recipes. Thanks for sharing with us all!!
Jessica Fisher says
It doesn’t matter at all. No worries. Carry on. 😉
Trischa says
Can I shred it in the pot for the last hour or will all the grease make it to greasy
Jessica Fisher says
I often do that, but the drippings go great in soup. Either way is delicious.
Chickiewickie says
I’m about to make this. And I read through all the comments. The one question I don’t see is, fat side up or down? In a regular oven I would do fat side up. Is that the same for crockpot? My normal go-to pulled pork recipe I slow cook in oven, sometimes up to 24hrs!
Jessica Fisher says
Personally, I don’t think it matters in a slow cooker. In the oven we do fat side up to keep everything moist and to flavor the meat with the drippings. The crockpot doesn’t usually run the risk of things drying out. It’s a personal preference, I think.
Janet says
Have you tried using liquid smoke in this recipe? Does is fare well in the slow cooker? If so, any suggestions on how much to use?
Thanks!
Jessica Fisher says
I have never used liquid smoke. Sorry I can’t be of more help.
Regan says
Has anyone tried this recipe with a pork loin? I have one on hand that I am not really sure what to do with & this sounded delicious!!
Jessica Fisher says
Pork loin can be tricky in the slow cooker. I’ve found it does better in a roasting pan in the oven. The same seasoning, however, would be delicious.
Sandi says
Months later, here’s my opinion: I almost always cook the pork loin in the slow cooker on low temp. It does create a lot of juice (not really fatty or greasy as that meat is usually pretty lean) so after you shred it, you need to let the meat sit in that juice and soak it back up again. If you drain the juice, the meat will end up really dry, especially when you reheat leftovers.
Jessica Fisher says
And here’s my revised opinion, months later. 🙂 Having recipe tested with this: https://goodcheapeats.com/2017/11/slow-cooker-pork-loin/ my current position is not to let pork loin go too long in the slow cooker. Then it does indeed get too dry. 6 hour mark on low seemed to be perfect. Too far after made it go dry.
Hilary F says
When I read “Best Ever Slow Cooker Pulled Pork,” I’ll admit that I took that as a challenge. But, I always love your recipes so I gave it a try. Wow, that was no overstatement. It is simply amazing!!! I love the spice rub. Many slow cooker roast recipes use seasonings that only make it suitable for one type of cuisisne (Italian, Mexican, BBQ, etc….). But, this us so versatile, I can imagine using it for countless recipes. Thanks again for yet another hit!!!
Jessica Fisher says
I am so glad you think so. Every time I make it I impress myself. LOL!
Carol says
I made it tonight, and everyone loved it! I cut the cloves and cayenne (we are wimps) in half. Perfect seasoning. Boys chose for me to add a little BBQ sauce after it was done and make pulled pork sandwiches. Our pickiest eater declared it the best ever. Thanks!!
Jessica Fisher says
Yay! That’s a true success when picky eaters like it!
Ashlee says
Hey there!!
I don’t have any cloves…do you think pooping a cinnamon stick in there would be a decent substitute for a little pop of that layer of flavor?
Jessica Fisher says
Sure. Let me know how it goes!
Terry calkins says
I do this recipe in the pressure cooker using a cup of water. The resulting broth is used to cook rice. If it is very oily I will cool the broth first and use the congealed fat to fry potatoes or start a roast. The shredded meat is packaged into 2. To 4 cup packages and used for BBQ pork sandwiches, burritos, tacos or chopped to add to shephards pie.
Jessica Fisher says
I did this with pork strips the other night, per your encouragement. The meat did not get as tender as it does in the slow cooker. I’m a newb when it comes to pressure cooking. Any suggestions? (I did 35 minutes with 10 min pressure release)
Lauren says
Is it best to do this with a thawed roast or can it be frozen ??
Jessica Fisher says
I prefer to cook thawed meat. It seems to have better texture.
ire says
Please try again- first try to fry the meat from all sides to seal the juices , then put the spices and some water.I buy the biggest shoulder I can fit in my IP ,bone in and do a 99 min.Afterwards , shred it,take the bone out and put it again for a short time so the meat can soak up the juice just as the other comments said .
Jessica Fisher says
Thanks for the suggestions!
Paula says
This was delicious–and so easy! We had family over for this meal, and my teenaged niece (who usually never eats pork) and nephew devoured there pulled pork sandwiches. My nephew loved how the meat didn’t have that sweet slick flavour/texture that some recipes have. I love healthy food and have type-one diabetes, so I loved that I didn’t have to add sugar or syrup. My sister-in-law asked for the recipe. :o) Note that I did put Paul Newman’s Bourbon BBQ sauce on the table to drizzle over if desired.
Jessica Fisher says
I love these stories! Thank you for sharing your success!
Heather B says
I have made pulled pork dozens of times, but I recently made this recipe for a family gathering and it received 10:10 scores from everyone- even my picky eater who doesn’t like to eat meat. He even had seconds! Can be used for bbq or for tacos- just add sauce or salsa. Fabulous!!
Jessica Fisher says
Yay! I’m always so thrilled to hear this. Thanks for sharing your feedback!
Jessie Stanek says
This recipe is Excellent! Moist with great flavor. Definitely will be making this again
Jessica Fisher says
Yay! So glad you liked it!
Meredith says
Love Love Love!!! I’m so happy I found this recipe. I first made it for a multi-family beach vacation and to say it was a hit would be an understatement! Everyone of all ages and even the pickiest of eaters couldn’t stop saying how it was the best pulled pork they’ve ever had. Now my husband requests it all the time. I put the rub on the roast the night before mostly because it saves me time in the morning, but it also gives it time for all the flavors to really get infused. Thank you for sharing such an amazing recipe!
Jessica Fisher says
So glad to hear that it is a keeper at your house! Great strategy for “marinating” it in the rub!
Kim says
This is now my go-to recipe for pulled pork. Love it, love it, love it! I make it without the cloves – that’s just my personal preference. The flavor is delicious and marries well with my favorite barbecue sauce.
Jessica Fisher says
Thanks so much for your feedback!
Brett C. Williams says
I’ve been using your recipe for years now. I use the specific spices and amounts listed and this comes out AWESOME every time. When I make it in the summer, I have to stop people from automatically putting on BBQ sauce. Then they try it and the WOW factor hits them! This is a proven winner.
I also make it on New Year’s Day. I put sliced up kielbasa on the bottom then layer one bag of sauerkraut (w\ juice) and one bag drained. I then put in ~ cup of brown sugar before putting the roast on top. Delish!
Jessica Fisher says
Thanks so much for the great feedback, Brett! I’m so glad to hear that it’s been so successful for you! #kitchenwinner 😉
André Bélanger says
The time preparing and cooking may take time but the taste is so delicious that one forgets time.
Debbie says
I used your recipe and it was fabulous! I took it to work and everyone raved over it, asking for the recipe needless to say there wasn’t any left to take home. I’m making another now, I cooked the first one on low for 12 hours. GREAT!
Jessica Fisher says
Yay! So glad you rocked it! Nicely done!
Jessica Fisher says
When you have a minute, can you come back and give it a starred review? Thanks!
Susan L Salomone says
in the crock pot as we speak! Cant wait to try it!
Sharlene says
Should I trim some of the fat before putting into crockpot?
Jessica Fisher says
You can if you want. It’s up to personal preference.
Francis Compton says
I was just wondering if this can be made with the shank or “picnic” portion of the roast.
Jessica Fisher says
That should be fine.
Desirae says
Hey there, I’m making this right now. It smells so good and I can’t wait to try it. My question is about the serving size. It says 211 calories per serving, but exactly how big is 1 serving size. I didn’t see it anywhere.
Jessica Fisher says
That figure is very approximate since we’re not going to be able to predict how much bone and fat comes in your roast. Our calculations are based on dividing an 8-lb bone-in roast (before cooking) into 16 portions. After fat and bone being removed, this is “probably” about 1/3 a pound, so I would say a pretty generous portion. Hope that helps!
Charles Carson says
Can I use this recipe on the smoker and how long for a 3.5 pounds to smoke
Jessica Fisher says
I don’t have a smoker, so I can’t help with this. Sorry.
Sarah says
Hi Jessica,
Thanks so much for your tips and amazing recipes! Quick question, do you think that if I put this on overnight 10-11 hours on low, and then left it in the slow cooker on warm until lunch (around 12 p.m.), that it would still be good? Worried about overcooking it, but would love to have the cooker do the work overnight!
Jessica Fisher says
It would probably cook too long that way. I would likely cool and refrigerate as early in the am as I could and then reheat for lunch or dinner.
Alexandra says
We used a 5.22 lb bone-in pork butt, so I was a little unsure about how long to cook it on low. So first, I want to say this came out amazing, but secondly for people who weren’t sure about different sizes, 6 hours on low worked perfectly. Falling off the bone yumminess!
Jessica Fisher says
Awesome! Thanks for providing that extra information, Alexandra. I appreciate recipe testers like you! 🙂