Not Too Sweet Granola

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites. We participate in other affiliate programs as well. For more details, please see our disclosure policy.

Start the day off right with homemade granola, not too sweet, made with lots of grainy goodness.

Not Too Sweet Granola - Start the day off right with homemade granola, not too sweet, made with lots of grainy goodness.

I go back and forth between buying breakfast cereal for its convenience and completely abandoning it for its questionable nutrition. Yes, really. I said that. I’m sorry, mamas, but it’s true. That thing that makes our life so easy is really not all that good for us. Call me the bad cop.

Most commercially-made breakfast cereals are full of sugar, salt, and heavily processed grains. My kids love them. Often that’s what they will choose for their birthday breakfast. And yes, on your birthday, I will buy chocolate-covered sugar bombs for breakfast.

I just won’t let you make a steady diet of it.

For regular days, I often buy Joe’s O’s from Trader Joe’s. At $2 a box it’s an okay “fill-the-gap” convenience item, but the ingredients list still has a lot of things I can’t pronounce. I’ll still buy it. Life is too short to freak out too much. But, when I can, I want my kids to have real food.

(Oh that this resolve will last all year long!)

For our regular breakfast rotation this winter I have the following on the menu, all baked items made with half white whole wheat flour or whole wheat pastry flour:

Homemade, Not Too Sweet Granola - Start the day off right with homemade granola, not too sweet, made with lots of grainy goodness.

These days, I’m making this granola. It’s not too sweet, it’s easy to mix up, and it disappears in the blink of an eye. My kids love it. And for the last two weeks, no one has noticed that there are no boxed cereals in the pantry. Win.

This batch fills three quart jars if I move fast enough. My people eat it up pretty quickly.

Demerara sugar is a lesser-processed sugar. You can use 1 1/4 cup honey or maple syrup if you’d rather and omit the sugar and water.

I’ve had my share of burnt batches of granola. No fun. Over time, I’ve found some tools that make the process easier, cleaner, and tastier.

Tools that make granola-making easier:

  • Sheet pans – I struggled forever with unevenly cooked granola in 9×13 pans. These sheet pans work so much better for me.
  • Silicone baking mats or parchment paper – these liners make it so effortless to remove granola from the pan and to prevent sticking and burning.
  • Quart-size canning jars – I love my jars. I use them to store baking mixes, sugar, bulk yeast, and granola.
  • A canning funnel – I like to fill my jars without a lot of mess or waste. A funnel makes it easy.
Subscribe to Good Cheap Eats
Read Newer Post
Read Older Post


  1. Stephanie M. says:

    We love granola too. Last summer, hubby and I spent a weekend at a bed and breakfast in the Amish Country in Lancaster, PA. For breakfast one morning, they served yogurt and granola parfaits. We loved it so much that I asked the woman who owns the home where we stayed and does all of the cooking if she would share her recipe with me. To my surprise, she was very obliging and did. Since then, I’ve been making it. It makes a huge amount so when I do make it, I share some with my neighbors and family and still have plenty left over for us. It freezes well too. I will be making some this weekend for the freezer because as mentioned in some previous posts, hubby and I are hosting a Valentines Dinner Party in a couple of weeks and the favors that I’ve decided to give out are “breakfast baskets”. Included with several other breakfast items will be this granola bagged up in clear cellophane “Valentine” bags.

  2. I made your cranberry/orange granola recipe last week. I will have to give this one a try. The other night I came to this site looking for a muffin recipe to make to go with our soup for dinner. My girl and I made the mix and match muffins with mini chocolate chips. They were amazing! This recipe is now my new favorite. Thanks!

  3. Jessica, I have two questions. My daughter has celiac disease, so the wheat germ and wheat bran are a problem. Any idea what I could substitute for those two ingredients? I think it’s too much to simply eliminate. Also, where do you find sunflower oil? I’ve seen it in several of your recipes, and I’m not finding it at the stores I shop at. I could go to a TJ’s, but it’s not very close.

    • Just omit the wheat ingredients. You could lessen the liquid just a touch and be fine.

      I’m finding the sunflower oil in lots of places now: Ralphs (Kroger), Trader Joe’s and Walmart.

  4. Very similar to my granola recipe. Try coconut oil! Delish. I often sub applesauce for part of the honey/sugar and no one notices.

  5. Nia Hanna says:

    This granola looks very good. Have you tried that Lazy Granola method over at Moneysaving Mom. Crystal’s easy method is great, it only cooks 10 minutes and then you go to bed and leave it in the oven overnight. I’ve tested it and its crisp in about 6 hours. I think I’m gonna try her method with your recipe, I just love that you’ve added coconut chips; I’ve got tons to use up ’cause we’re just not eating lots of monkey salad like we used to.

  6. so if you wanted craisins or nuts in the granola, would you add that before or after the baking? I’m thinking possibly the nuts before and the fruit after?

  7. Yummy! I’m going to make this. We eat so much oatmeal I am ready to purchase in 25 lb. bags (as soon as I run out of what was purchased for a killer sale price at Sprouts). Thank you for your continued inspiration.

  8. Jennifer Hoffman says:

    Is there any way to make this recipe a bit more budget friendly? Can everything be found at trader joes or whole foods? I’m not familiar with some of the ingredients

    • I don’t think you can find anything at Trader Joe’s except the oats, salt, oil and vanilla. You can use more oats and less of the other things and use brown sugar instead of demerara if you like.It won’t be the same but it will be cheaper.

  9. Kristen Martin says:

    Thank you for breakfast recipes! Do you think I should try to sub something for coconut chips or just omit? Can’t find them anywhere (no TJ’s nearby).

  10. Have you ever used this to make granola bars ?

  11. Susanna McLeod says:

    Do you think that nutritional yeast would work in place of the wheat bran in this recipe? I have a box of nutritional yeast that I’ve only used from once, and I want to use it up. Would it taste funny?

Share Your Thoughts