Wondering how to cook a turkey? We’ve got you covered with these easy tips that result in a delicious roast turkey.
I’m hosting Thanksgiving, but I don’t know how to do it. I’m not sure how to cook a turkey. What in the world am I going to do?
Don’t panic. We’ve all been there. At least once.
Everyone whose ever cooked a turkey has felt at a loss as to how to do it – the first time. Those who’ve cooked more than one turkey have learned from their mistakes.
If you find yourself wondering what in the world to do with this turkey — and all this stuff inside it! — this post is for you.
This post was originally written for my kid sister. She had moved away from our home state to the historic village of Williamsburg, Virginia where she found herself cooking a turkey for the first time.
I was planning to write this kind of post, but had abandoned the idea. And then she said, “I really need you to write that post.”
So, here we are.
I have cooked a turkey — or turkey breast — at the holidays for more than twenty-five years. Holy smokes.
That’s a lot of turkeys now that I think about it.
And trust me, there have been some mishaps: not thawing the bird in time and running out for a fresh turkey the night before, flinging turkey all over the kitchen trying to lift it out of the roaster, throwing out my back trying to get it into the oven, you name it.
So far, though, the only casualties have been my back — and the turkey, of course.
While I don’t consider myself a turkey expert, I have learned a thing or two these past three decades. Namely: how to cook a turkey easily.
How to Cook a Turkey the Easy Way
You won’t find special tricks or techniques in this post.
No paper bag overnight method. No fancy pants brines. No flipping the bird halfway to maximize tender breast meat.
Nope. No way. No how.
Just a classic method for cooking a turkey that produces a delicious main dish without a lot of hassle, expense, or complexity.
Honestly, it’s basically the way I always saw my mom do it. Plus, some of the aforementioned, learned-the-hard-way strategies.
What do you need to cook a turkey?
Cooking a turkey should not be intimidating, provided you have the right equipment for the job. Here’s what you’ll need:
Roasting Pan and rack/lifter – We’re going to cook the turkey in the oven, so we need a roasting pan. You can get a roaster that comes with a removable rack or a standard roasting pan without a rack. You can buy a turkey lifter separately.
The turkey lifter is not a necessity, of course, but it will help you avoid flinging turkey all over the kitchen. Ask me how I know.
You can use a disposable aluminum roasting pan, but be sure to stabilize it with a baking sheet underneath.
Turkey bag – I am old school, and I love the turkey size oven bag. It may not be the fancy way, but it works for a foolproof turkey. I use the brand that I buy at the grocery store.
Inevitably, the little silicone tie will go missing. Don’t worry about it. You can use kitchen twine to tie the bag shut or trim off a half-inch off the open end of the bag and use that as a tie.
Instant-read thermometer: Whichever method you choose, you’ll want an instant-read meat thermometer. Testing the internal temperature of the bird is the only truly accurate way to know that it’s been cooked enough. 165 degrees F is ideal.
There’s a small notch in the side of a standard instant-read thermometer. Make sure you’ve inserted it until the notch is covered. You also don’t want to hit bone or an air pocket (like the inside of a whole turkey). You want to measure the temperature of the meat.
Since the dark meat takes longer to cook, you’ll want to measure the temp of the dark meat. If it’s done, the whole bird should be done. Insert the thermometer into the thigh, parallel to the bird. There’s a great explanation of this over at The Kitchn.
Large stock pot or slow cooker – You don’t need this for the turkey, but you’ll want to have this ready for making turkey stock afterward. Likewise, make a note to have your turkey stock ingredients ready.
What do I need to do to cook a turkey?
Some forethought is necessary in getting the bird to table. Read through these steps in enough advance time to complete them.
Thaw the turkey in advance.
A turkey will cook best if it’s not frozen. While there are methods out there for cooking a frozen turkey, thawing ensures that your turkey will cook in a reasonable amount of time.
For ultimate food safety, thaw the turkey in the refrigerator in a pan to catch the drips. I knew a lady whose turkey dripped all over her pumpkin pies. Ewww. Make sure you place it in a pan to catch drops.
Allow sufficient time for thawing, about 6 hours per pound. Hop on over to the Butterball site for a nifty thawing calculator.
Yes, you can quick thaw it in a sink of cold, runnning water. But, seriously, who wants to mess with that?
Remove the turkey from the wrappings.
In the old days it was considered standard practice to rinse the turkey prior to cooking. Due to cross contamination concerns, the USDA now advises against washing poultry.
Instead, remove the turkey to a tray, discarding the wrappings. There will be a fair amount of juices in the wrappings, so have the trash can nearby and be sure to wash your hands and any surfaces that come in contact with raw juices.
You will also need to pull out the bag of giblets and the neck from inside the bird. These are often in two separate ends of the turkey. Don’t ask me why.
And yes, you’ll be fine touching the guts. No big deal. You can discard them or cook them to use in broth, gravy, and stuffing.
Season the turkey.
There are a range of seasoning options. I am pretty lazy most of the time because I count on the gravy to add zest to the plate. I use my FishMama Seasoning Salt, but you can use your favorite spice mix if you prefer.
Many recipes will call for mixing the seasoning and herbs with soft butter and then spreading this all over the turkey. I prefer to take a little short cut, like I do with my roast chicken. It’s a lot less messy!
Cut the butter into thin slices. Season the slices generously with seasoning mix and slip the seasoned butter pats under the skin. This is much easier and way less messy.
Place the turkey in the oven bag.
Place the turkey rack in the roasting pan. Place the turkey bag on the rack. Add 1 tablespoon flour to the bag. I have no idea why, but it’s the instruction from the bag manufacturer.
Place the turkey in the bag, adding the onions to the cavity. Tie the bag closed and cut six slits in the bag to allow air to escape. Now place the turkey in the oven and set a timer, according to the chart in the box of bags. An 8 to 12 pound turkey should take about two hours, while a larger bird can take up to three hours.
Make sure you’ve got room in your oven.
Unless you have a large oven or more than one oven, you’re going to need to make sure that the other hot dishes you plan to serve have adequate time to cook. Everyone wants some of that hot real estate, so plan accordingly.
Your turkey will need to rest for 30 to 40 minutes, so that should give you time to get the other hot things hot. If need be, arrange to use a toaster oven or crockpots to keep things warm.
Make sure your turkey’s cooked.
The best way to calculate the doneness of a bird is to measure the internal temperature. The USDA says 165° is safe. There is a chart inside the box of roasting bags or you can consult the cooking time table here.
What do you do once the turkey is cooked?
Your turkey’s cooked! But, you’re not done yet. There are still something’s that you’ll need to do before you’re ready to serve.
Remove the turkey from the bag.
Your turkey should look beautifully golden brown. Carefully cut the oven bag open and remove it from around the turkey. It will be full of delicious drippings.
Careful not to burn yourself, move the bag around so that the drippings pour into the pan. Using the turkey lifter, remove the turkey from the pan to a platter or carving surface and discard the bag.
Strain the drippings and make gravy.
While the turkey is resting, you can finish off your other dishes as well as whip up some gravy.
Those juices in the bottom of the roasting pan? Those are liquid gold! Strain those into a glass measuring cup. The fat will rise to the top. You can skim this off or use it as a substitute for butter in your gravy recipe. Use the drippings as a replacement for the stock in the recipe.
If you don’t want to make gravy, save the drippings to add to soup and stock. So good!
Carve the turkey.
Carving is a lost art. The men of Jane Austen’s time were raised to know how to carve the bird, the joint, and whatever big hunk of meat was served à table. Today, not so much.
It takes some practice to make it look good, so don’t feel bad about carving the turkey in the kitchen where no one can see you. Read my tutorial for how to carve a chicken. The same process works on turkeys.
Enjoy your meal, but don’t forget the the turkey leftovers!
What do I do with turkey leftovers?
Remove the meat from the bones.
Package any leftover meat, either to freeze or to eat later, within 2 hours of cooking to preserve food safety. Since you will probably feel too lazy to do it later, I recommend, trimming it from the bones, and chopping or slicing the cooked meat right away.
You can use the cooked meat over the next three days, storing it in the fridge in the meantime, or stash it in the freezer, wrapped and labeled, for another time. Head here for some great Leftover Turkey Recipes That Will Wow You.
Make stock with the bones, etc.
Toss any bones, skin, drippings, or other turkeyish stuff that you have left and make turkey stock. The bones are full of flavor and nutrients that will go into the stock for fortifying soups and sauces later.
Do it right away so that you will feel extra productive when the meal is finished and you’re enjoying a second slice of pumpkin pie.
How to Cook a Turkey
- 1 tbsp unbleached, all-purpose flour
- 1 whole turkey size will vary depending on your needs
- 1/2 cup butter sliced into 8 slices
- 1 tbsp FishMama Spice Mix
- black pepper
- 1 onion quartered
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Place a turkey size oven bag in a roasting pan lined with a rack. Place the flour inside the bag.
- Remove the turkey from the wrappings and place on a rimmed pan.
- Season the butter pats generously with the seasoning salt. Slide the butter pats under the turkey skin, distributing them evenly around the turkey.
- Season the outside of the bird generously with salt and pepper. Place the onion pieces inside the turkey cavity.
- Place the turkey inside the prepared bag. Tie it shut with the enclosed silicone zip tie. Tuck the corners of the bag into the roasting pan.
- Place the roasting pan into the heated oven and bake for several hours, according to the size of the turkey. Consult the time chart included with the oven bag. The turkey's internal temperature should be 165 degrees F.
- Remove the turkey from the oven. Slice open the bag and remove the turkey to a serving platter or carving surface. Allow to rest at least 30 minutes.
- Any drippings remaining in the bag or roasting pan are delicious for gravy, soups, and stocks. Drain and use for these purposes.
- Carve the turkey and serve.
This post was originally published in November 2011. It has been updated for accuracy and relevancy.