How to Cook a Pot Roast in the Slow Cooker

When I was a young newlywed, I’d always heard of the beauty of the slow cooker and what delicious roasts you could cook in one. Well, the first time I tried, it was an utter disaster. The meat was tough and chewy. I’m not sure it was even edible. I gave up on roasts for about five years.

And then I learned a few tricks. I asked friends who made delicious roasts. I read recipes. And I figured out some general guidelines for a great tasting roast.

The following are some tips to help you enjoy roasts, like we do now, with the ease of the slow cooker.

The Meat Matters

Some cuts of meat are meant for braising, others are for dry roasting. Braising is when food is browned in fat, then cooked, tightly covered, in a small amount of liquid for an extended period of time, exactly like the slow cooker. I like to use boneless chuck roasts for this type of dish.

I prefer this cut because it is generally fairly lean, easy to carve, and fairly economical. I stock up on roasts when they are $2.49/pound.

Brown the Meat First

My experience is that just tossing a hunk of meat into the slow cooker is not going to result in the depth of flavor or tender texture that you will get if you brown the meat first. Yes, it’s an extra step, but it totally pays off in the end. It is worth the ten minutes and a dirty pan.

I simply salt and pepper the roast well and then brown it on all sides in a little hot oil in a skillet. Remove the roast at that point and place it in the slow cooker.

Add flavor

Next I want to add some flavor. I saute some aromatics in the drippings left in the skillet. Add chopped onions, garlic, or shallots to the pan. Cook them on low heat until clear and starting to brown lightly. You can even saute chopped carrots, turnips, mushrooms, or other hearty vegetables at this time.

Add liquid

Once the onions are tender and browned, stir in some liquid to deglaze the pan. This could be water, broth, juice, tomato sauce, wine, or beer. You don’t need a lot, only about 1/4 to 1/2 cup. As you add the liquid, stir it well with the aromatics and scrape up any browned bits from the bottom of the skillet. You can also add fresh herbs and spices at this point.

Cook it slow

Add this mixture to the slow cooker. Cover. Turn the heat on low and walk away for 6 to 8 hours. The meat should be meltingly tender at the end of the cooking time. Remove it from the cooker and while it rests, you can create a gravy or a pan sauce with the remaining liquid.

Now, what’s stopping you?

Would you rather subscribe by RSS?
Read Newer Post
Read Older Post

Comments

  1. Just in time! I’m cooking a roast this weekend, and I was looking for new ideas….
    Thanks!

  2. My roast ALWAYS falls to pieces in the crockpot. I’d love to have a pretty roast like the one pictured:) I’ll have to try your method.

  3. I just began my love affair with the slow cooker this year. It has literally changed my life. I love this recipe and will put it on the menu for next week. Try one of mine – this is my fave: http://www.myjudythefoodie.com/2011/11/slow-cooking-beef-tips/

    Thanks so much for sharing. looks great

  4. This is going to be Sunday dinner this week. Thanks for the tips!

  5. so… you don’t submerge the meat in water??? (sorry for the seemingly silly/dumb question but mom never used slow cooker in her so it’s still a mystery to me)

  6. Your recipe sounds delicious! I thought I’d add my own method to the mix. My roast falls to pieces too, but I like it like that! I put the roast directly into the slow cooker. Then I combine brown gravy mix with 1-2 cups of water and pour it over the meat. If I want veggies, then I cut up carrots, potatos and onions and put that in before the gravy. (I have also used dry onion soup mix but I prefer that with pork and the brown gravy with beef).

  7. Thank you for posting this! I was just commenting to my husband on how I needed to start doing more meats in the crock pot, but I wasn’t sure how to do it.

  8. Have you had good luck with any other kind of roast besides chuck? The chuck roasts around here are often very fatty. That’s living in the South…. =)

  9. This was amazing! So tender & juicy! I buy beef in bulk, a quarter at a time from a local farmer, so I had to use a bone-in chuck roast but still it worked great.

  10. Brooke Kingston says:

    This recipe is worth it’s weight in gold…we ate the best pot roast I’ve ever made last night after following your recipe. We used beer like you do in the photos, and the aromatics and nearly caramelized onions made all the difference. The gravy for this roast was to-die-for, and the meat was so flavorful and tender. I have been searching for seven years to find the right slow cooker pot roast recipe, and yours just nailed it! Thank you so much…this is divine dinner!!

    • @Brooke Kingston, fun! And the beauty is that it’s a non-recipe. You adjust the flavors to match what you have. You can make unlimited combinations with success. So glad that it worked well for you!

  11. Rachel Anne says:

    Awesome! The method of browning first made an alarmingly huge difference in the flavor. Great tip!

  12. I’m new to this and this recipe sounds wonderful! I would love to print it, but I don’t see a printer friendly recipe. Help!

    • There isn’t a “recipe”; it’s a method that you can follow on your own. It is really forgiving. As long as you get the right kind of meat, you can’t mess it up.

Share Your Thoughts

*