Favorite Slow Cooker Pot Roast

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. We participate in other affiliate programs as well. For more details, please see our disclosure policy.

A slow cooker pot roast is a welcome sight on a cold and busy evening. The slow braise allows the flavors to develop, making this one of my favorite recipes.

Favorite Slow Cooker Pot Roast | Good Cheap Eats

When I was a newlywed, slow cookers did not have a great reputation. They were as outdated as the avocado-colored refrigerators they were designed to match. I still went out and bought one. I was hip before hip was cool, ya know?

Seriously, though, I knew that the slow cooker could do things that would make meal prep so much easier for me. Like make stew like Mom used to make.

I’m on my second and third generation slow cookers now; they continue to serve me well for soups, sauces, chilis, and all kinds of braises, including my new favorite pot roast recipe.

Slow cooker pot roast is one of my favorite dishes. It takes me about fifteen minutes to prep it for the crock and then I walk away. I can do school, run errands, watch a movie, read a book, all while knowing that dinner is cooking itself. Jane Jetson, the future is here!

Beef prices haven’t been too favorable to allowing us slow cooker pot roast or otherwise these days, but recently I found chuck roasts for $3.77/pound. I had several $3/$15 meat purchase coupons from Ralphs, so you can guess that I STOCKED UP. ($3.57/pound is about as cheap a beef cut I can ask for.)

I need to slow myself down from going through the stash too quickly, but we did enjoy a few rounds of it so I could run this slow cooker pot roast recipe through its paces.

Favorite Slow Cooker Pot Roast | Good Cheap Eats

One thing that I’ve done differently in this version is that I’ve made sure it would produce a gluten-free gravy at the end. I think gravy is one of the beautiful fringe benefits of a slow cooker pot roast. I wanted one that was 1. EASY and 2. good for folks eating gluten-free/Whole 30 and all that jazz.

The secret thickener is tomato sauce. Yay! It works like a charm. Not only does the tomato sauce add a nice flavor to the jus, but it also thickens it just enough for it to serve as a decent gravy. The jus also makes a marvelous mix-in for soup when you have just a few bites of meat and sauce left. We’ve, ahem, enjoyed this a lot lately.

Another new twist is a spice blend I’m working on. I wanted a really simple spice blend to use quickly in dishes. I’m currently calling it the oh-so-creative name of Basic Spice Blend, but it works. It’s basic, but it’s packed with flavor. I’ll write a full post on it when I have run it through its paces in other dishes. It is great in this slow cooker pot roast. So, be sure to jot down the ingredients once you print the recipe below.

Basic Spice Blend

Combine these five ingredients in a small jar. Mix well, cover, and store in an airtight container: 2 tablespoons smoked paprika, 1 tablespoon garlic powder, 1 tablespoon kosher salt, 1 tablespoon black pepper, 1 tablespoon dried thyme.

This slow cooker pot roast is perfect for these cooler days, nights when you need a little comfort food, and whenever you find a good deal on chuck roast! It’s perfect with mashed potatoes, but feel free to add your favorite vegetables. You could even just add carrots and potatoes to the pot and call it good.

Tools I use for this recipe:

About Jessica Fisher

I believe great meals don't have to be complicated or expensive. There's a better way, and it won't take all afternoon.

Subscribe to Good Cheap Eats
Read Newer Post
Read Older Post


  1. Sally says

    Oh my goodness that looks good!

  2. Cheri A says

    I made pot roast in the slow cooker yesterday with celery and carrots cooked in it! I’ve never thought to add tomato sauce. I may have to try it. I usually just add 3/4 cup of water to the cooker and then make a little slurry of cornstarch or tapioca starch at the end to thicken the gravy up. As an aside, my daughter also requested your easy garlic green beans on the side, which I happily made! <3

    • I was so happy to know someone else uses tapioca for the gravy. Tapioca seems to smooth flavors (whatever that means); somehow the celery, carrots and onions are much tastier when tapioca is added.
      I just think the veggies ruin the roast flavor, and the veggies themselves never taste very good – so I add the tapioca.
      I store the leftover box of tapioca in the fridge dehydrator – it lasts forever.

  3. Sally says

    I made this last week and it was delicious. I didn’t make it in the slow cooker, I made it in the oven. Since I’m a single I had some leftover. One day I just reheated the leftovers “as is.” I also made hash and used some of the meat to fill tacos. I may use what’s left in soup or stew.

  4. Julie says

    Have you added carrots and potatoes to the crock pot as well? I’d love to have all of dinner done but I’m not sure if that would change the liquid to solid ratio too much.

    • Yes, you absolutely can. I just have picky kids; some of whom don’t like the texture of crockpot carrots and potatoes. Plus, I like serving this on mashed potatoes. Don’t worry about changing the liquid. Just throw those in the pot!

  5. Jared Larson says

    Would this mix taste ok with chicken? I am not fond of pork or beef, I know weird!

    • I have never made this with chicken, so I can’t really say. I wouldn’t make it in the slow cooker, but possibly roast it in the oven.

  6. Jennifer says

    Would you add in the potatoes, careots, and green been at the very beginning or at some point later?

    • You could add potatoes and carrots at the beginning. I’d add green beans later until you want them really, really soft.

Share Your Thoughts