Wondering what you can make in the slow cooker? Better question is what can’t you make in the slow cooker. Here’s how I experimented for a month of slow cooker recipes.
Using your slow cooker on a regular basis can help you stop eating out and make home-cooked meals so much easier.
Want to save this post?
Enter your email below and get it sent straight to your inbox. Plus, I’ll send you budget recipes and money-saving tips every week!
Yep, I used a slow cooker more than 30 times in October. I’d like to say it was every day, but some days I used it more than once and there was one day when I got caught up in binge watching a French murder mystery and I forgot.
But, I did do it.
When I told my family about my challenge, they were super skeptical. Crockpot? All month? What are you gonna make?
I told them it would be a surprise. And it was.
We certainly didn’t expect the answer to be Slow Cooker Cheesecake, but life has some delicious surprises like that.
In most cases, good surprises. I tried new recipes. I tried new cooking styles. I shared them with the Club. They tried new things, too.
And it was super fun!
Until it wasn’t. I’ll admit this last week was a drag to think of what to make—until I went back to testing pumpkin cheesecake. Ahem.
Last December I planned for Crocktoberfest to be this month. I’ve been looking forward to this month for almost a year, and now that it’s over, I’m really looking forward to next October when we can do it again!
Wondering how I used the slow cooker this month? Here’s my list. The bold are items that were wins for us.
Scroll down for the winning recipes that are posted here on Good Cheap Eats.
- Lawnmower Taco
- Chocolate Cheesecake
- Salsa Verde Beef
- Carnitas Tostadas
- Applesauce
- Fingerling Potatoes
- Steel Cut Oats
- Party Mix – I wondered why I never bake party mix. I don’t like it. Plus, it burned in the slow cooker, so I still don’t like it. FAIL
- Nachos – decent but not worth the effort when the oven is so much quicker. Not a fail, but probably won’t do again.
- Spiced Cider – Nice for heating for a crowd. Will maybe do again?
- More oats.
- Baby back ribs – super good, only they are so tender, they fall apart!
- Pumpkin Cheesecake – turned it on warm instead of high, FAIL
- Pumpkin Cheesecake again – pan touched the crock and overheated, FAIL
- Sweet and Sour Pulled Chicken
- Chocolate Fondue
- An experiment with meatballs and a throw together BBQ sauce, FAIL
- Chocolate Cheesecake, again. Tested for type of cream cheese.
- Quickest Chili in the West
- Meatloaf in the Slow Cooker
- Chocolate Cheesecake, again. For pictures.
- Whole Chicken
- Chicken Stock
- Steel Cut Oats again.
- Enchiladas
- French Dip Sandwiches
- Chocolate Cheesecake. To freeze for Thanksgiving.
- Cranberry Sauce.
- Vegan Chocolate Lava Cake. Okay, not super exciting without the butter, milk, and egg. Not a fail, but probably won’t do it again.
- Cheesy Potatoes. What’s not to love?
- Sauerkraut and Pork
- Pumpkin Cheesecake. Determined to nail it. Not quite there yet.
- Quinoa Chili
I Used My Slow Cooker Every Day This Month & Here’s What I Made
Best Slow Cooker Recipes
Lawnmower Taco Casserole
This taco casserole has been a longtime favorite in our family, yet I've never made it in the slow cooker. I assumed it would get mushy, but the reverse is actually true. The chips stay crisper than when baked.
While assembly is exactly the same in the slow cooker, the cook time is a little longer. The advantage, however, is that you could easily take the casserole to a potluck or prep it farther in advance and let people eat when they're ready.
Salsa Verde Beef
We've been making this delicious taco filling for a long time. It's actually one of my son's favorite meals ever. He prefers it in burrito bowls rather than in tacos.
One note: chuck roast cooks down a lot, and even though it was a large roast, it really only made enough for one meal for our family.
If you want to feed a crowd or freeze extra for later, do 2 to 3 roasts. Two should fit in the 4-qt round slow cooker. Three would fit in the 6-qt.
Carnitas Tostadas
I often make Carnitas Soft Tacos, but it'd been awhile since we'd made the "little meats" into tostadas. So easy and good!
A pork shoulder always makes a lot so one cooking session fed us many nights.
Slow Cooker Applesauce
I'd forgotten how good Slow Cooker Applesauce was until my daughter forgot that we still had some and she dished me up applesauce from a jar. Gag.
Never buying that stuff again.
Instead, I crunched the numbers and found that if I can get apples for less than $1/pound, it's in my best interests to make it myself.
So delicious on oats in the morning! Or afternoon! Or evening!
Slow Cooker Potatoes
This was an amazing surprise dish. These Slow Cooker Potatoes that have less than five ingredients were gobbled down in minutes.
Baby potatoes are on sale this week at Ralphs so I can't wait to make them again.
I plan to make these as an additional side at Thanksgiving since they're naturally dairy-free/vegan, and so easy to make.
How to Cook Steel Cut Oats in the Slow Cooker
I'd cooked oats overnight in the slow cooker and been disappointed with the blown out results. Oats cooked to smithereens!
Instead, cooking them for just a few hours resulted in perfectly cooked oats that need no stirring or babysitting. These are now on my regular rotation for breakfast prep.
Sweet and Sour Pulled Chicken Sandwiches (Slow Cooker Prep!)
These Sweet and Sour Pulled Chicken Sandwiches have long been a favorite of ours. That was before we'd ever had bahn mi.
Now that we have, this chicken sandwich filling is going up higher on the rotation. We had these sammies once on hawaiian rolls and once on baguette with bahn mi toppings. Both are delicious!
Crockpot Chocolate Fondue
Such an easy dessert! You'll wonder why you ever mess with baking. Simple to make dairy-free or even vegan, Crockpot Chocolate Fondue is where it's at!
Quickest Chili in the West - Slow Cooker or Stovetop
This chili is a no-brainer. So easy to mix together on the fly, it cooks up quickly on the stovetop or at your leisure in the slow cooker.
SImple, yet packed with flavor, definitely put it on your meal plan this week!
How to Cook a Whole Chicken in the Slow Cooker
Cooking a chicken in the slow cooker is a pretty easy process that gives you lots of cooked meat for any number of recipes.
Then once you've carved the chicken, throw the bones and trimmings back in the slow cooker and make stock. Something from nothing that's so easy and takes soups and sauces over the top!
How to Make Chicken Stock in the Slow Cooker
Homemade chicken stock has been referred to as "liquid gold". Rich and delicious, it's great for enhancing soups, stews, rice dishes, and sauces with savory goodness.
Whether you buy a rotisserie chicken or cook your own, be sure to make stock with what's left!
Crockpot Enchiladas - Assemble Dinner in Minutes
Crockpot Enchiladas take minutes to make, but have all the comfort of rolled enchiladas. This easy recipe can be adapted for any number of fillings and sauces. Whatever you have on hand will result in a delicious enchilada supper.
Slow Cooker French Dip Sandwiches
French dip sandwiches are the ultimate fall comfort food, even more so when the slow cooker does the work!
Easy Homemade Cranberry Sauce for People Who Think They Don't Like Homemade
This cranberry sauce is a must-make every fall and winter. My kids eat it plain out of bowls for weeks. Trying it in the slow cooker was a fun experiment, and one that we'll repeat.
Be sure to leave the lid off for a few minutes at the end of cooking to help it thicken just a tad.
These Cheesy Potatoes are Ultimate Comfort Food
How can you go wrong with Cheesy Potatoes in the slow cooker? While it didn't get the trademark, crunchy top, we stuck it in the oven with breadcrumbs for a few minutes right before serving and it worked just as well.
It was also delicious without the breadcrumb top, so I think either way is a winner.
Sauerkraut and Pork
This is a three-generation family favorite. Despite my husband's dislike for sauerkraut, I've slowly accustomed my kids to the dish. We have it for lunch on days my husband's not home.
You can prep it in the pressure cooker which is how my mom always made it, but I've been cooking it in the slow cooker for close to 20 years and appreciate the slow braise.
Quinoa Chili with Three Chiles
Now that one of my kids eats vegan, this has become a go-to chili recipe. The quinoa and beans provide enough protein for everyone and the three chiles give it just the right kick of flavor.
It's super freezer-friendly, making for easy snacks and lunches, too.
How to Cook a Pot Roast in the Slow Cooker
If you need a versatile pot roast that you can mold to what you have, this is the one for you. Raid the fridge and pantry and you'll easily come up with some mix and match flavors to complement your next roast dinner. So easy and good!
Slow Cooker Meatloaf
Meatloaf has been a classic American dinner for decades. Make it the easy way next time with this simple Slow Cooker Meatloaf Recipe!
Slow Cooker Chocolate Cheesecake
This Slow Cooker Chocolate Cheesecake will score big points with everyone at your table. A chocolate cookie crust and a filling of cream cheese, sugar, egg, chocolate, cream, and vanilla extract bakes in the slow cooker for the creamiest cheesecake ever!
Marissa
Crocktober went better than expected. I was worried when everyone was tired of soup/stew/chili during the first week. It made me have to meal plan a little, which always helps. Your enchilada and sauerkraut with pork were favorites. We tried a little of everything. Pasta sauce, hot & sour soup, broccoli beef, 2 different granolas, pizza chili, pork tenderloin, cornbread, cream cheese chicken, sweet potato soup, loose meat sandwiches, shepherds pie, pumpkin pie pudding, baked oatmeal, cream beef, refried beans, cabbage soup, Rice Krispie treats, teriyaki tofu, honey mustard chicken, buffalo chicken lasagna, rice pudding, pancakes, cocoa, steel cut oats, applesauce, clam chowder, fried rice, honey lentils, pasta E fagioli soup, 15 bean soup, and sauerkraut pork.
Jessica Fisher
Wow! You did awesome, Marissa! Great job.
Ms. Vicke G. Owens
I love to make food different kind of ways thanks!
Amber Herrick
Hi,
Where is the baby back ribs recipe? I’m not seeing it.
Thank you.
Jessica Fisher
Oops. That’s not one that is posted yet. Sorry about that. I basically rubbed them with Montreal seasoning and put them in the crock (sprayed with nonstick spray) on HIGH for 4-5 hours. They were super tender, but impossible to cut apart without their falling apart.
Stacey
You’re an inspiration!!
Jessica Fisher
Thanks, Stacey!