Buttered Maple French Toast Casserole

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. We participate in other affiliate programs as well. For more details, please see our disclosure policy.

Enjoy a leisurely breakfast or brunch with this buttered maple French toast casserole. It’s make-ahead and will make someone happy. Very happy.

Buttered Maple French Toast Casserole - Enjoy a leisurely breakfast or brunch with this buttered maple French toast casserole. It's make-ahead and will make someone happy. Very happy.

Our family loves French Toast. I love that you can put dry bread to good use. Waste not, want not, right? I particularly love the idea of a French Toast Casserole. However, many recipes I tried in the past left me with a very gooey, custardy concoction. Not my favorite. I like a bit of crunch.

A few years ago I happened upon the idea of buttering the bread that goes in the casserole. In this way, you get a nice, toasty, crunchy top. There’s still the custard layer on the bottom. It’s like the best of both worlds. And since the bread holds its shape so well, you can eat it out hand.

I created a delicious Buttered French Toast Casserole with Almonds and Ginger in Not Your Mother’s Make-Ahead and Freeze Cookbook. It is amazingly good. If you’ve got the book and haven’t tried it yet, I highly recommend it. The candied ginger, dried fruit, and almonds give it a wonderful combination of textures. Yum-O!

Buttered Maple French Toast Casserole - Enjoy a leisurely breakfast or brunch with this buttered maple French toast casserole. It's make-ahead and will make someone happy. Very happy.

I use Trader Joe’s Ciabatta for this recipe and whip it up lickety-split. I realized last time I made it that I now need to make two pans. My family loves this and gobbles it down in a heartbeat. (Make croutons with any leftover bread.)

One of the great things about it — besides the amazing flavor and texture and it’s quick prep time — is that you could make it ahead of time and stash it in the refrigerator or freezer. You’ll get variations in texture, but the flavors are still amazing.

This dish is great for lazy breakfasts and brunches. Bonus: It’s naturally sweetened with maple syrup, making it a real, whole foods, kinda meal.

About Jessica Fisher

I believe great meals don't have to be complicated or expensive. There's a better way, and it won't take all afternoon.

Subscribe to Good Cheap Eats
Read Newer Post
Read Older Post


  1. Stephanie M. says

    This looks so delicious, Jessica. I will definitely be giving it a try. We love French toast and this looks like a wonderful variation from the regular egg soaked white bread that I usually use. Also, just thought I’d tell you that today, for the first time, I made your Italian sandwich rolls. It took me two tries. The first time, the dough just refused to rise, at all. My yeast was good and I followed the directions exactly. So figuring that it might be the flour, I ran out and bought a new bag. Although the one I had wasn’t old at all. Since I bake so often, flour never gets a chance to get old. Anyway, that dough starting rising immediately. I divided the dough into 16 pieces and molded them into thin, short rolls, as directed, but they baked up a little smaller than hot dog buns. I also put two slits in each roll with a razor and sprayed them three times with a water sprayer as I’ve always done when I make French Bread during the baking process. In any event, as small as they were, they were absolutely delicious and we ate them as dinner rolls with butter. I froze the rest and when they’re gone, I’ll be making more, maybe round next time. Unfortunately, they are entirely too small for sandwiches. I guess I rolled them a little too small. But thanks for posting this wonderful recipe and I look forward to making them for many years to come. 🙂 Practice makes perfect!

  2. cherie says

    You know, I’m so glad that I have you to do my recipe tweaking for me! I have always shied away from french toast casseroles for that exact reason – now this hasn’t made my life torture or anything LOL – but it is a convenient dish and this is a great solution – the ciabatta is also a sturdy bread so that’s another good idea! Love TJ’s ciabatta – just delicious and better than mine!

  3. Leslie says

    Is any maple syrup supposed to be mixed in with the eggs? Wondering if that step is missing.

    • Janel Piersma says

      Good catch! Yes, the 2 tablespoons of maple syrup are supposed to be mixed in to the egg mixture. We’ve updated the directions. Thanks!

  4. Ellen says

    I’ve tried the make ahead french toast recipe with ginger and almonds. It was delicious and enjoyed by the family (although I did leave a plain section for the picky one). I froze one and it didn’t last but one night in the freezer after we enjoyed the first pan. Definitely want to make 2 pans of this too. I also tried it with some frozen blueberries over the top which we liked a bit more than the dried fruit combination. Thanks for the recipe! We’ve enjoyed it.

    • I’ll have to try it with blueberries. Did you use the ginger still?

      • Ellen says

        I did, because I liked the bite of the ginger. The kids weren’t loving ginger, so next round it will be on 1/2.

  5. Nia Hanna says

    I make a version of baked french toast too. I got my recipe while watching the TODAY show several years ago. I used store-bought sourdough the first time around. But since discovering Five Minute Bread I like to use that especially when there’s leftover bread to be used up.

  6. Nicole says

    Just served this to a bunch of relatives visiting from overseas. Not only did they clean the pan down to the scrapings, but the house smelled delicious for hours! It was so easy to make too. I love easy wins! Thanks 🙂

  7. Marie says

    This was just the Casserole dish I was looking for. IL have one question, if I make it on Saturday morning and don’t freeze it, will it be OK for Sunday morning? I wasn’t sure how long it could sit in the fridge before heating it.

    • I’ve done it overnight, but not longer than that. I think it should be fine, but I’m not 100% sure.

  8. Jodi says

    How does this reheat? we won’t eat it all at once and i don’t want to waste it! thanks.

    • I actually prefer to eat the leftovers cold, but yes, you could reheat in the toaster oven.

  9. Jaime says

    So easy and absolutely delicious! I topped mine with some maple syrup, a dollop of crème fraiche, and some strawberries. Yummy!

  10. Crystal says

    Since it’s just me that I would be making it for, has anyone baked it, then packaged it up individually and froze it? That would work for me.

    • I don’t think I have done that, but you could definitely try it. You could also scale the recipe to make a smaller batch.

  11. I made these the other day, cut my bread an inch thick because an inch and a half seemed really thick. Used homemade gluten free bread and it worked out perfect! I have several of your other recipes printed out and waiting to be altered gluten free as well.

    • Good to know that you enjoyed it with gf bread. We really don’t like mushy french toast, so the thickness helps that. 😉

  12. Jenni Lane says

    This is good but if you use another kind of bread you should probably toast it first or it will be still tasty but mushy ?

  13. Candy says

    I am Going to try this with Trader Joe’s sliced French brioche it’s thick it should work and i am freezing for a week will let you know

Share Your Thoughts